I've done my own digging on most user-friendly islamic dating app for modern Muslims and come up short. Muslims apps is the clearest case of it — nothing improves until you ask a specific question in the first message. It is worth separating out values-first daters here, because with islamic apps, what decides it is the depth of the profile fields, not the badge on the download page.
You get further if you report problems early instead of blocking quietly, which is the whole problem with islamic apps. I judge islamic apps on one thing: most of the disappointment traces back to how often the same faces reappear.
For muslims apps in particular, the deciding factor is the ratio of matches to conversations, having tried a handful of these. Here is the uncomfortable bit about most user-friendly islamic dating app for modern Muslims — the platform hides read receipts on the free tier, and the ratio of matches to conversations suffers for it. Happy to be told I'm asking the wrong question about islamic.