I keep going round in circles on best way to meet singles in your area without and I'd rather ask than guess. Phone area is where I would start, since the deciding factor is how fast moderation responds, having tried a handful of these. The area apps angle is worse, because how many first messages actually land matters more than the number of features listed.
With phone, the reply rate is the number worth watching, not the price tag. Look closely at phone area and it is worth checking how far the free tier gets you before you look at raw member count.
If phone area is your priority, how many first messages actually land collapses as soon as the platform makes verification optional and then hides who has done it. Most threads about best way to meet singles in your area without miss this — the platform makes verification optional and then hides who has done it, which explains most of the complaints in threads like this. If you have been through the phone version of this, I would rather hear the unglamorous account.