Hoping someone here has actually tested christian dating websites that focus most on theological compatibility rather than just read about it. Speaking as one of members looking for shared values, I would say most of the disappointment traces back to the time it takes to get a first reply — theological included. The share of verified profiles moves the needle further than the badge on the download page, on the evidence I have, which is the whole problem with compatibility sites.
Same story on theological compatibility: it is worth checking the share of verified profiles before you look at the follower count on their socials. The picture changes for values-first daters once theological compatibility enters it: what decides it is how well it works on a weak connection, not star ratings from strangers.
If theological compatibility is your priority, the practical move is to run a reverse image search on suspiciously polished photos. My honest read on christian dating websites that focus most on theological compatibility: you get further if you turn off precise location until you trust someone. Anyone who has tested theological sites properly, please weigh in.