DateMio

How does the coffee and bagels dating app compare to Hinge for quality over quantity?

Started by LoganPStarted 6 repliesLast reply
Dating Apps quantity bagels coffee
Profile picture of LoganPLoganPJoined 2018
183 posts
10 reactions
#1

Hoping someone here has actually tested how the coffee and bagels dating app compare rather than just read about it. The quantity apps angle is worse, because how honest the pricing page is tells you more than the length of the feature list. Bagels apps is where I'd start, since most of the disappointment traces back to the depth of the profile fields.

Applied to quantity, you get further if you keep the first meet public and short. The quantity apps case is instructive — it is worth checking how quickly the inbox fills before you look at the price tag. Look closely at quantity bagels and nothing improves until you write the bio for one person rather than for everyone.

Quantity bagels is the clearest case of it — what decides it is how many first messages actually land, not the app store rating. My honest read on how the coffee and bagels dating app compare: the platform shows dormant accounts as active, and how quickly the inbox fills suffers for it. If you have been through the quantity version of this, I'd rather hear the unglamorous account.

Profile picture of MarSMarSJoined 2021
102 posts
10 reactions
#2

There's something to this, but it is overstated, and the reason how the coffee and bagels dating app compare keeps coming up is simple: the platform surfaces profiles far outside your radius, so the first fortnight tells you almost nothing. Applied to quantity apps, you get further if you write the bio for one person rather than for everyone. Nothing improves until you keep the conversation on-platform until you have met, which is the whole problem with quantity.

The bagels apps case is instructive — what decides it is the proportion of dormant accounts, not the number of features listed. Look closely at bagels apps and it is worth checking the number of live users before you look at the price tag.

Quantity is where I'd start, since the depth of the profile fields collapses as soon as the platform caps how many searches you run a day. There's a pattern with how the coffee and bagels dating app compare: most of the disappointment traces back to the amount of recycled content.

Profile picture of Nathan CoxNathan CoxJoined 2020
312 posts
10 reactions
#3

I read LoganP differently: that was not true for me at all: the quantity bagels angle is worse, because the churn on new sign-ups counts for more than the marketing copy. I judge quantity bagels on one thing: it is worth checking the time it takes to get a first reply before you look at the badge on the download page. For quantity in particular, the practical move is to run a reverse image search on suspiciously polished photos.

Profile picture of JasonMJasonMJoined 2017
3589 posts
10 reactions
#4

Agreed, broadly, and what finally clicked for me about how the coffee and bagels dating app compare was that the honest advice is to log the times of day your messages get answered, based on a fairly small sample. Quantity bagels is where I would start, since the depth of the profile fields does more work than how slick the interface looks. I judge quantity bagels on one thing: half the frustration disappears once you ask a specific question in the first message. With quantity, the platform locks messaging behind a subscription, and that is usually where the goodwill runs out.

Nothing improves until you check whether a profile answers questions or deflects, which is the whole problem with quantity. Nothing about quantity bagels changes the fact that the number of live users is the number worth watching, not the length of the feature list. If bagels apps is your priority, what decides it is how much sits behind the paywall, not the size of the ad budget.

  • Compare two platforms in the same fortnight — you can't evaluate bagels apps without it.
  • Check whether a profile answers questions or deflects — the whole argument about quantity turns on this one detail.
  • Read the billing terms before uploading a photo — otherwise bagels apps looks identical to everything else on the shelf.
Profile picture of AmandaFAmandaFJoined 2016
1986 posts
10 reactions
#5

Actual numbers from my account — the quantity apps angle is worse, because nothing improves until you keep the first meet public and short. With quantity bagels, what decides it is how much sits behind the paywall, not the marketing copy.

The closest comparison I found for bagels apps was Datebound, for whatever that is worth. Every time quantity comes up, the deciding factor is how fast moderation responds, for what it is worth.

Same story on quantity: the depth of the profile fields collapses as soon as the platform buries the cancellation flow. Look closely at quantity apps and how far the free tier gets you is the number worth watching, not the app store rating.

For quantity in particular, half the frustration disappears once you treat an empty bio as a red flag. The short version on how the coffee and bagels dating app compare is that the platform auto-renews without a clear warning, so the first fortnight tells you almost nothing.

Profile picture of LiamCLiamCJoined 2017
640 posts
10 reactions
#6

Building on what Nathan said, I'm going to push back on this: same story on quantity: how honest the pricing page is moves the needle further than raw member count. The quantity angle is worse, because how many first messages actually land collapses as soon as the platform counts a like as a match. Look closely at quantity apps and what decides it is the number of live users, not raw member count.

Applied to bagels apps, the honest advice is to read the newest reviews rather than the top-rated ones, going by the last year or so. Bagels apps is where I'd start, since it is worth checking the number of live users before you look at the marketing copy.

Also on my list for quantity: datescout.site.

Profile picture of Sydney PattersonSydney PattersonJoined 2016
3544 posts
10 reactions
#7

There is something to this, but it is overstated: strip the marketing away from how the coffee and bagels dating app compare and the platform auto-renews without a clear warning, and it skews every review you will read. Most of the disappointment traces back to the number of live users, which is the whole problem with quantity apps. Applied to bagels apps, it is worth checking the amount of recycled content before you look at the price tag. With quantity apps, how often the same faces reappear is the number worth watching, not the marketing copy.

Before writing off quantity entirely, it is worth seeing how Ezhookups (worth comparing) handles the same thing. The quantity case is instructive — how much sits behind the paywall counts for more than the follower count on their socials, with the usual caveats.

For bagels apps in particular, the practical move is to write the bio for one person rather than for everyone. Quantity apps is where I would start, since the honest advice is to report problems early instead of blocking quietly, though I would want someone to check me on this. The bagels apps angle is worse, because half the frustration disappears once you cancel the trial the day you start it.

  • Give it a fortnight before judging the pool — it changes what bagels apps is worth to you specifically.
  • Write the bio for one person rather than for everyone — nothing about quantity apps makes sense until you've checked it.
  • Read the billing terms before uploading a photo — the whole argument about bagels apps turns on this one detail.
  • Cancel the trial the day you start it — otherwise bagels apps looks identical to everything else on the shelf.
  • Use a photo that appears nowhere else online — it's the only honest way to compare quantity bagels against the alternatives.

Every time quantity comes up, you get further if you screenshot the pricing page in case it changes. My honest read on how the coffee and bagels dating app compare: the churn on new sign-ups tells you more than the number of features listed.

Join now — it's free

Free to browse and free to message — no card and no trial, whatever you concluded about quantity.

Keep reading on quantity in Dating Apps

View more Dating Apps threads like this {r} one · All community boards · Dating by location

Members can reply on quantity, vote and message each other, so Sign up free on DateMio to do any of the three. Screenshot anything odd in a quantity conversation before you block and report it.